43 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin Alexander's avatar

Nice to see The Passionate Ones getting some love! It’s in my list too. I might’ve missed it, but it feels like this one just sailed under a a lot of radars this year?

Also: “Has forward momentum” is a great description of Billboard Heart.

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

I'm honestly still not checking most lists, but there was a fair amount of chatter about it in the discord server (that representative sample of music criticism lol). it's too bad it's not getting more attention!

Expand full comment
Lavender Sound's avatar

I only listened to Nourished by Time for the first time last week and…i have mixed thoughts? But it seems like music critics who spend most of their time online are obsessed with him despite him eternally living under the radar.

Expand full comment
Kevin Alexander's avatar

I can’t speak for anyone else, but in my case, this record reminds me of a very specific era of late 80s/early 90s R & B and New Jack Swing. I have to imagine nostalgia is part of the calculus.

Expand full comment
Lavender Sound's avatar

People really do love nostalgia and music critics are far from immune to that! I like that 9 2 5 song a lot but the album loses its momentum for me toward the end, even though the last song is clearly inspired by our beloved Prince

Expand full comment
Eric Stirpe's avatar

Oh wow I've never listened to Daughter of Swords before but this album is just lovely. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

you're so welcome

Expand full comment
melissa's avatar

Oh I just found out about the pôt-pot record on Bandcamp Friday! I’m really enjoying it!!!!!

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

i think I learned about it from Bandcamp as well!

Expand full comment
Indie Scientist's avatar

ditto!

Expand full comment
Joi's avatar

Forgot about that Daughter of Swords album! Lots of my favorites listed here

Expand full comment
Lavender Sound's avatar

I added Daughter of Swords and Hilary Woods to my listening list! Is Deerhoof a fair RIYL for Water from Your Eyes? The second song on the album (the one with the giant distorted power chords) reminds me so much of them

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

yeah. i think that's a fair comparison!

Expand full comment
Shanté's avatar

i just replayed Nourished By Time’s album again last night—i’m sure that i’ll mention it somewhere in my recap, yet IDK if it’ll be ranked! i definitely didn’t give it as much attention as it deserved, but there are plenty of standout tracks.

Expand full comment
Ken Asher's avatar

This list fully accomplished your mission of exposing this old head to new music. I previously knew only four of these artists and had only listened to the Open Mike Eagle record prior to consuming the list.

I count nine releases out of the fifteen that immediately struck me and are in rotation now.

This after I spent all day yesterday badgering anyone who would listen with Victor Jones recommendations. AND HE TASTES LIKE CHICKEN.

Thanks for all you do Gabbie!

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

HIGH FIVE MY FRIEND

Expand full comment
Geoff Neill's avatar

If you play Cutthroat over the Natalie Bergman video you kind of get the end of the Punk Rock Loser video. 😂

The Little Barrie record is certain of a spot on my list of 20 records worthy of a #1 spot. Love it! It was the first record this year that blew me away.

Records you will either include or leave off next week: Geese (this generation's Radiohead?), Sprints (a sophomore letdown, or just a different vibe?), Car Seat Headrest (standout track: The Catastrophe), The Happy Fits (this year's Bad Nerves), Youth Sector (play The Ball on NYE!), The New Eves, Shaggo (hope they found a sock and a friend), Die Spitz (band that sounds actually most like Nirvana since the 90s), Panic Shack, Kathryn Joseph, Florry, Teen Mortgage (did I tell you I went to their show that got shut down early because a crowd surfer almost pulled a heavy light fixture down on the mosh pit? Punk rock!), Cloakroom (hardcore slowcore), Isabella Strange (shame you hate EPs, because I think you'd really like this).

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

i don't hate EPs, I just need a goddamn break 😭😭😭

Expand full comment
Geoff Neill's avatar

Oh I get it. I'll be honest, I'm not sure how it snuck into my playlist! Also I just relistened and two of the songs are good, the other three only okay. I also forgot from my already-too-long list above Strawberry Fuzz (having fun and making "punk" rock music) and Laveda (90s rock recorded in a bedroom).

Expand full comment
Ken's avatar

Natalie Bergman...

1) how the heck did I miss this earlier?

2) stumbling across it now is the reason I'm here.

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

so happy to read this!

Expand full comment
Liz EM's avatar

Deep Sea Diver has had a hold on me all year, but especially since I saw them live. By far my favorite album this year. Also, Jessica Dobson is a killer guitar player - I left the show with my face appropriately melted!

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

jealous!!!

Expand full comment
Indie Scientist's avatar

SHAME HIVE RISE UP!!! I gotta check out a good chunk of these

Expand full comment
David Coleman's avatar

Delighted to see my #1 album of 2026 - Anna von Hausswolff's "Iconoclasts" - included. And Hilary Woods and Open Mike Eagle too. Great records!

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

are you already living in the future, david?

Expand full comment
Mark Nash's avatar

I’m glad I’m starting to see some names I recognize here. That Anna von Hausswolff album blew me away, quite frankly and it’s a top ten for me. Also loved the Deep Sea Diver release. The Little Barrie & Malcolm Catto and Natalie Bergman albums would’ve been there if I’d expanded my top 50 to a top 70. Now off to listen to the half dozen artists I’ve never even heard of before!!

Expand full comment
V McDre's avatar

Quite a bit to get through here for me, Gabbie. But most importantly, I didn't realise Little Barrie had done anything after Long Hair... and I watched BCS religiously 🤯

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

and this is me trying to keep it manageable!

Expand full comment
MLEE's avatar

How long must we wait for a band that reminds you of The Mekons?

Expand full comment
Gabbie's avatar

dude I recommend more post punk than pretty much any other genre. just pay attention/ask nicely maybe?

Expand full comment
MLEE's avatar

I do pay attention, appreciate your stack, and thought I ask nicely.

Expand full comment
Simon Chivers's avatar

Cool. I was thinking of something like this for jazz rock fusion bands.

Expand full comment