New Bands for Old Heads

New Bands for Old Heads

New Music DNA - Pt. 4: A Mixtape for Your Oldest Brother, Justin McElroy

Justin McElroy of My Brother, My Brother and Me on having "uncool" music taste, chasing that fizzy feeling of recognition in new music, and the irrelevance of middle age.

Gabbie's avatar
Gabbie
Aug 04, 2025
∙ Paid
Quick links for the TL;DR crowd:

1) My interview with Justin McElroy
2) Justin’s music DNA
3) A preview of Justin’s playlist
Full playlist and bonus video available here.
Please enjoy a candid and unflattering photo from our Zoom call in lieu of any sort of professional photography.

Justin McElroy is a podcaster, an author, and an entertainer.

“It took me many years to feel comfortable saying that,” he told me, “but I think at this point, it's all right. I entertain people for a living. That's my job.”

As a day-one fan of My Brother, My Brother and Me, I was delighted when Justin followed this newsletter’s TikTok precursor a few years back. And more delighted still when he agreed to talk with me about his music tastes and nostalgia.

In this fourth installment of New Music DNA, we discuss dorky music tastes, the idea that one could age out of listening to certain types of music, and constantly chasing familiar feelings when discovering new music.

And of course I make Justin a playlist, too.

Tir…

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Gabbie.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Gabbie · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture