The Best Albums of May 2026
Today, we're doing a show AND tell.
Remember when I complained about how little context release calendars have? And then I made an adorable imaginary info card that I would use in my fantasy new album tracker?
Sorry, I’m not announcing a new website or anything like that — I’m only slightly delusional! But I am going to do a related experiment in this album roundup.
If you like the new format, maybe I’ll keep it up. If you don’t, don’t tell me about it — I accept only compliments, not criticism 🥰.
For newbies, a quick reminder that I tend to ignore most major releases in the so-called “indie mainstream,” (or indeed the actual mainstream) even if I happened to love them. My goal isn’t to put you on the most esoteric music by any means necessary. But you don’t need me to tell you about the new Paul McCartney, Violet Grohl, or Boards of Canada, either.
What were your favorite records from May? Share with the class!
All month-by-month best of lists are here.
The Best Albums of May 2026
9 albums. 1 Playlist. No rankings.
Legend:
🎯 → if you only have time for one…
📼 → most nostalgic/accessible
🧩 → most challenging
Keep scrolling for the May playlist.
Modern Woman - Johnny’s Dreamworld
Start with: “Offerings”
Cocanha - Flame Folclòre
Start with: “Clam”
7 albums to go!
Still to come — IDM revival, teenage punks, Swedes on the dance floor, Indonesian soul, and more melodramatic grunge.
Paid subscribers also get access to the full band directory, exclusive playlists, vinyl and ticket giveaways, and a Discord server for tons of community recs and listening parties.
Don’t forget join us at 5pm Eastern on Sunday June 21st for our next radio hour!
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to New Bands for Old Heads to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.